December Holidays
Frequently Asked Questions
Petsi Pies offers two special pies for the December holidays:
Eggnog Cream Pie: gingersnap crust filled with an eggnog-flavored custard and topped with whipped cream.
Peppermint Chocolate Cream Pie: chocolate cookie crust filled with chocolate custard and topped with peppermint-flavored whipped cream.
Like other Petsi sweet pies, the holiday pies are available in three sizes:
Small, 5” serves 1-2; $10
Medium, 8” serves 4-5; $20
Large, 10” serves 8-10; $38
What pies are on the December Holiday menu?
Can I order a pie for the holidays?
Yes, but holiday pie orders must be received by Tuesday, December 17th. Place your order online by the 17th for pick up anytime between December 18 and December 24.
We are unable to reserve/hold pies on December 23 and 24. Please come to the bakery at 285 Beacon Street, Somerville to select your pies from the shelf on those days.
Pie Around Town
We partner with many local farm stands and specialty stores in Greater Boston to bring pies closer to you. See below to see if there is a local business selling Petsi Pies near you during the December holidays.
Allandale Farm, Brookline
City Feed, Jamaica Plain
Volante Farms, Needham
Mahoney’s, Winchester
D’Agostino’s, Arlington
Black Sheep Market, Cambridge
Powisset Farm, Dover
D’Agostino’s, Winchester
Crescent Ridge Dairy
Walden Local Meat offers its members apple and pecan pies w holiday share order.
Shubie’s, Marblehead
Fruit Center Marketplace, Milton & Hingham
Idylwilde Farm, Acton
We will be baking a variety of the pies on our menu, as well as scones, biscuits, teacakes, and cookies. We will also have a limited number of pies from our holiday menu—eggnog cream and peppermint cream pies.
Will other flavors be available?
Saturday, December 21 and Sunday, December 22, 9am - 3pm
Monday, December 23, 8am - 5pm
Tuesday, December 24, Christmas Eve, 8am - 1pm
Wednesday, December 25 and Thursday, December 26, CLOSED
Friday, December 27, 8am - 5pm
Saturday, December 28 and Sunday, December 29, 9am - 3pm
Monday, December 30, 8am - 5pm
Tuesday, December 31, New Year’s Eve, 8am - 1pm
Wednesday, January 1 - Thursday, January 9, CLOSED FOR WINTER BREAK
What are the shop hours for the December holidays?
What if I want to order a large number of pies the week before Christmas?
We appreciate your enthusiasm! Large orders (more than 20) are typically taken in with at least 2 weeks notice. Email catering@ petsipies.com to inquire.
