Petsi Pies has changed its East Cambridge address!

We love you East Cambridge…

After (nearly) a full year of residence in East Cambridge, we have outgrown the adorable, quaint and cozy walls of 441 Cambridge Street.

Now you can find us at 594 Cambridge Street, just a block and a half down the way on the other side of the street.

Here you will find the same pies, pastries, soups, salads, sandwiches and beverage menu you’ve come to love, with 4 times the seating capacity!

We look forward to seeing you soon…

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Peanut Butter, Chocolate Bourbon & Banana Pie!

We are ringing in the New Year here at Petsi Pies with a delicious new treat!

Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Bananas, oh my! For this pie we use our Chocolate Cookie Crust filled with a mix of Chocolate and Bourbon, layered with sliced bananas and topped with a creamy Peanut Butter frosting and Ganache.

We were recently featured on a Cooking Channel show titled Unique Sweets. They took over the kitchen and it was lights, camera, action for our owner Renee McLeod. In this show we present our Mississippi Mud pie as well as a new Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Banana Pie!

Tune in on January 11th at 1:30PM, January 12, 2015 1:00 AM, January 12, 2015 9:00 PM or January 17, 2015 3:00 AM (ALL TIMES EASTERN).

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Christmas 2014

Ordering for the 23rd and 24th of December is now closed.
We will try to have as much on hand for those who were not able to get an order in in time!  We are so sorry to anyone inconvenienced by this.

  The original post for our Holiday menu is below…


For Christmas this year why not celebrate with pie?

Our Christmas menu is now finalized and we are happy to announce some of our year-round favorites along-side some holiday specials!
We will be offering all of these pies in a 10″ size which typically serves about 6-8.

Classic Apple
Apple Crumb
Apple Pear Cranberry with a Walnut Crumb topping
Salted Caramel Apple
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Mississippi Mud
Chocolate Cream
Brown Butter Pecan
Cherry Crumb
Mixed Berry

Our Holiday Pies are:

Eggnog Custard
The traditional Christmas favorite in a pie! A decadent custard pie made with rich and creamy eggnog

Chocolate Peppermint Cream
Rich chocolate cream in a ten-inch chocolate cookie crumb crust, topped with minty whipped cream

  • We will also be offering hand decorated gingerbread cookies and sugar cookies for order.

We will soon have online ordering available, so please check back for a link


You can call the bakery to place an order

285 Beacon st:
Tuesday, December 23rd (7a-7p) & Wednesday, December 24th (7a-2p)

31 Putnam ave:
Tuesday, December 23rd (7a-6p) & Wednesday, December 24th (CLOSED)

Cambridge st:
Tuesday, December 23rd (7a-7p) & Wednesday, December 24th (7a-2p)



Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Potato, Mushroom, Rosemary and Gruyere

We’ve heard your requests and starting Monday, December 8th our winter seasonal savory pie is back!

Red potatoes roasted with rosemary, a trio of mushrooms, and a sprinkle of Gruyere make this seasonal savory pie perfect for any event.

We are offering slices and full pies starting Monday so place your orders now!


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Closed Friday, November 28th

This Friday, November 28th we will be closed at all locations in order to recover from a fabulous Thanksgiving. We will be offering all of our pie selections on Saturday and Sunday and would love to see you then!

More importantly: thank you all for making this Thanksgiving so fabulous! You all trekked out in the snow while navigating construction on Beacon St to come visit us and we so greatly appreciate seeing you!



Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Ordering is now closed for Thanksgiving 2014

We at Petsi Pies love Thanksgiving.
It’s our favorite holiday.
Maybe the only bad part for us knowing there is a limit to how many pies we can produce.
So with a heavy heart, we must call a close to recieving holiday orders.

If you have already placed an order, you can still change/cancel/increase your order, however for us to get all the work done, we can no longer accept new orders.

We thank everyone who has asked for pie, and apologize to those we are unable to get in this year.

Thank you and Happy Thanksgiving

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Ghouls, Goblins, and Pie. Oh My!

Trick or Treat, come and eat!

Why not celebrate Halloween this year with one of our Fall seasonal pies?

Pumpkin Pie is always a treat! With a blend of four delicious spices its guaranteed to make your Halloween celebrations special.

If you’re looking for something a bit less traditional try our Sweet Potato Pecan pie. It is our classic Sweet Potato pie filling made with roasted sweet potatoes, a bit of fall spices, and topped with a rich and sweet layer of brown butter pecans.

While you’re inviting all of the witches and ghosts over for a Halloween party we will be creating your perfect party desserts. Give us a call and order your Halloween pie today!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Apple Pear Cranberry with a Walnut Crumb Topping

October is upon us and the leaves are turning. As the seasons change we are introducing some Fall flavors to our menu.

Apple Pear Cranberry pie is joining our line-up!

This pie is filled with a combination of  crisp Granny Smith apples and sweet Cortland apples, mixed with juicy pears and tart Cranberries. A blend of seasonal spices and a brown-sugar walnut topping make this an irresistible addition to your Fall dinner table.

Save your fork, there’s pie!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Butternut Squash, Caramelized Onions, Gorgonzola and Walnuts

It’s time for our favorite Fall savory pie to join our line-up.

This seasonal pie allows us to enjoy all of our favorite Fall flavors with a bit of style.

These scrumptious pies will be made available at all three locations starting this week. Feel free to call and order one or just come on in to see our regular daily selection!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Chicken Pot Pies

It seems that Fall is just beginning, and it is time for our seasonal pies to jump back into gear.

This week we will start assembling our award-winning Chicken Pot Pies!

Petsi Pies’ Chicken Pot Pies are made with roasted chicken, fresh carrots, green peas, red russet potatoes and spanish onions.

Our homemade gravy and a lot of love make these a Fall and Winter seasonal treat-They are assembled here at the bakery and taken home for a delicious home cooked meal!

Call us on Wednesday to reserve one for this week!



Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment