Salted Caramel Apple

As we dive into August, here at Petsi Pies we are welcoming back our Salted Caramel Apple pie!

It is spilling over with decadent Caramel, loaded with Granny Smith Apples and bursting with a mixture of flavorful spices.

Its a wonderful addition to an outdoor barbecue or a night at home.

Order your’s today by calling us at the bakery or come on in and find one on the shelf!


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment


Hosting a summer gathering?

We would love to provide all of your guests with some tasty treats!

Sunday Brunch?

Our breakfast sandwiches are off the charts, and our savory pies are to die for. Our Summer seasonal Tomato Provencal will be starting this Sunday!

Weekday book club?

We also have a bundle of summer salads, and delectable sandwiches for some great lunch or dinner parties.


A sweet treat rounds out any event!

Try our Peach or Peach Blackberry summer pies, or our fancy Strawberry Rhubarb.


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

No dairy, no eggs, & all vegan!

Upon your request we have started creating some of our delicious fruit pies with a special vegan twist!

We have turned our flaky pie crust into a vegan friendly alternative and managed to maintain the quality that our customers have grown to depend on.

We our currently offering our Peach Blackberry pie with a vegan crust and filling. We have all three sizes and are offering slices.We will be offering some of our other favorite flavors come this weekend and on into the rest of the summer.

For anyone who is avoiding dairy, eggs, honey, or any animal by-products but still loves a glorious pie, come on by!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Memorial Day 2014

On Monday the 26th we will be closed as a memorial for all of the glorious men and women who have fallen while serving in the Armed Forces.

If you are having a celebration that day and are in desperate need of a pie feel free to come in on Sunday the 25th. Most of our pies stay well for a day and will be great for a Memorial Day party that Monday.

Try our Chocolate Bourbon Pecan with a soft, sweet, and rich filling topped with brown butter pecans

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Upon your request…

We have begun creating our delicious peach pie!

These days the seasons just can make up their minds! So, we’re starting summer off early with a Bang.

Our Peach Pie is made with our classic pie crust filled with ripe peaches baked down with cinnamon, cardamom, and nutmeg.


Our Peach Blackberry pie is a great twist on a classic. This pie is made with our delicious walnut crumb topping and brewed down with some fresh blackberries.

Come on into any of our locations and try a slice of both!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Mother’s Day 2014

A mother is a person who seeing there are only four pieces of pie for five people, promptly announces she never did care for pie.

This Sunday, May 11th we are presented with the opportunity to get mom a whole pie just for herself!

Whether it be our Spring Favorite: Strawberry Rhubarb or a Year-Round Favorite: Classic Apple Pie this Sunday will be a great day to celebrate all of the Mother figures in our lives with a slice of pie.

This one’s for you Mom!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Strawberry Rhubarb

The Dogwoods, Magnolias and Cherry Blossoms are blooming. Its time for some Barbeques, trips to the park, and a little less hibernating!

Spring has finally arrived! In honor of this glorious season we have begun making our Strawberry Rhubarb pie.

Strawberry Rhubarb is a spring classic here at Petsi Pies. Made with sweet Strawberries, tart red Rhubarb and topped with a crispy Oat Crumb Topping or a classic pastry crust.

Be careful taking this one to a party, you won’t get a bite before it disappears!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Easter 2014!

Easter is on April 20th this year and we are so excited to offer some of our favorites for your celebrations!

We have a special menu for ordering on Friday the 18th and Saturday the 19th.
For Easter, we can only take orders for 10″ pies:
Strawberry Rhubarb
Mixed Berry
Cherry Crumb
Brown Butter Pecan
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Classic Apple
Apple Crumb
Lemon Meringue
Chocolate Cream
Savory Pies (all Varieties)
Key Lime
Mississippi Mud

For ordering we will also be making:
Our moist 6″ coconut cake with cream cheese frosting topped with a delicate layer of shredded coconut flakes.
Crisp, buttery shortbread cookies hand decorated in sweet frosting.

Ordering is now closed, however we will try to have as much of our menu available for pickup Friday and Saturday.

Thank you and have a lovely Easter!


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Roasted Asparagus, Smoked Mozzarella & Roma Tomato

Due to the beautiful spring weather that has finally graced us with its presence we, here at Petsi Pies, have started making our Roasted Asparagus, Smoked Mozzarella and Tomato Savory pie!

Whether for breakfast or dinner our savory pie brings a flavorful medley of Spring vegetables to your table. Every bite promises a depth of flavor and a delightful texture.

This, as well as our other three flavors of savory pies are made everyday in the bakery in our 10″ large size. We are also more than happy to slice you a piece for you to enjoy!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Pi Day ordering is closed

Pi(e) day is turning out to be quite the holiday this year at Petsi Pies! Thank you for all of our customers who have gotten your orders in. Unfortunately, we are no longer able to take orders for pies on Friday the 14th.
We will, however, have hundreds of large pies for sale at the bakery that day for pick up; like our scrumptious Apple Crumb, filled with both Cortlandt and Granny Smith apples mixed with a blend of spices and gently topped with a white crumble!
So come on in and we’d love to celebrate 3.14 with you!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment